Here it makes a difference because both call 1 and 2 can run asynchronously, call 1 on a separate thread and call 2 on some other thread, which might be the main thread. CompletableFuture method anyOf and allOf, Introduction to CompletableFuture in Java 8, Java8 || CompletableFuture || Part5 || Concurrency| thenCompose, Java 8 CompletableFuture Tutorial with Examples | runAsync() & supplyAsync() | JavaTechie | Part 1, Multithreading:When and Why should you use CompletableFuture instead of Future in Java 8, Java 8 CompletableFuture Tutorial Part-2 | thenApply(), thenAccept() & ThenRun() | JavaTechie, CompletableFuture thenApply thenCombine and thenCompose, I wonder why they didn't name those functions, They would not do so like that. Why did the Soviets not shoot down US spy satellites during the Cold War? Seems perfect for this use-case. However, if a third-party library that they used returned a, @Holger read my other answer if you're confused about. My problem is that if the client cancels the Future returned by the download method, whenComplete block doesn't execute. How do I generate random integers within a specific range in Java? Views. If you get a timeout, you should get values from the ones already completed. Basically completableFuture provides 2 methods runAsync () and supplyAsync () methods with their overloaded versions which execute their tasks in a child thread. 3.3. How to delete all UUID from fstab but not the UUID of boot filesystem. Regarding your last question, which future is the one I should hold on to?, there is no requirement to have a linear chain of futures, in fact, while the convenience methods of CompletableFuture make it easy to create such a chain, more than often, its the least useful thing to do, as you could just write a block of code, if you have a linear dependency. Is it ethical to cite a paper without fully understanding the math/methods, if the math is not relevant to why I am citing it? thenCompose() should be provided to explain the concept (4 futures instead of 2). Do German ministers decide themselves how to vote in EU decisions or do they have to follow a government line? Iterating through a Collection, avoiding ConcurrentModificationException when removing objects in a loop, jQuery Ajax error handling, show custom exception messages. Which part of throwing an Exception is expensive? Not the answer you're looking for? This was a tutorial on learning and implementing the thenApply in Java 8. In that case you should use thenCompose. Does With(NoLock) help with query performance? Remember that an exception will throw out to the caller, so unless doSomethingThatMightThrowAnException() catches the exception internally it will throw out. This method is analogous to Optional.flatMap and Does With(NoLock) help with query performance? I don't want to handle this here but throw the exception from someFunc() to caller of myFunc(). forcibly completing normally or exceptionally, probing completion status or results, or awaiting completion of a stage. See also. Implementations of CompletionStage may provide means of achieving such effects, as appropriate. Meaning of a quantum field given by an operator-valued distribution. extends U> fn). It's a brilliant way to manage timeout in java 8 where completeOnTimeout is not available. This method is analogous to Optional.flatMap and subclasses of Error or RuntimeException, or our custom checked exception ServerException. Does Cosmic Background radiation transmit heat? Other than quotes and umlaut, does " mean anything special? If your function is lightweight, it doesn't matter which thread runs your function. What tool to use for the online analogue of "writing lecture notes on a blackboard"? How can a time function exist in functional programming? @Holger: Why not use get() method? Kiskae I just ran this experiment calling thenApply on a CompletableFuture and thenApply was executed on a different thread. How do I apply a consistent wave pattern along a spiral curve in Geo-Nodes. What tool to use for the online analogue of "writing lecture notes on a blackboard"? The end result will be CompletableFuture>, which is unnecessary nesting(future of future is still future!). Did you try this in your IDE debugger? The second step (i.e. All exceptions thrown inside the asynchronous processing of the Supplier will get wrapped into a CompletionException when calling join, except the ServerException we have already wrapped in a CompletionException. rev2023.3.1.43266. https://stackoverflow.com/a/46062939/1235217, The open-source game engine youve been waiting for: Godot (Ep. If you apply this pattern to all your computations, you effectively end up with a fully asynchronous (some say "reactive") application which can be very powerful and scalable. The asynchronous nature of these function has to do with the fact that an asynchronous operation eventually calls complete or completeExceptionally. 3.3, Why does pressing enter increase the file size by 2 bytes in windows, How to delete all UUID from fstab but not the UUID of boot filesystem. I get that the 2nd argument of thenCompose extends the CompletionStage where thenApply does not. extends U> fn). The class will show the method implementation in three different ways and simple assertions to verify the results. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format! Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. I can't get my head around the difference between thenApply and thenCompose. It provides an isDone() method to check whether the computation is done or not, and a get() method to retrieve the result of the computation when it is done.. You can learn more about Future from my . You can achieve your goal using both techniques, but one is more suitable for one use case then other. See the CompletionStage documentation for rules covering The article's conclusion does not apply because you mis-quoted it. I have tried to reproduce your problem based on your code (adding the missing parts), and I don't have your issue: @Didier L: I guess, the fact that cancellation is not backpropagated is exactly what the OP has to realize. super T,? CompletableFutureFutureget()4 1 > ; 2 > normally, is executed with this stage's result as the argument to the In this tutorial, we learned thenApply() method introduced in java8 programming. Do I need a transit visa for UK for self-transfer in Manchester and Gatwick Airport. @1283822, The default executor is promised to be a separate thread pool. Simply if there's no exception then exceptionally () stage . Software engineer that likes to develop and try new stuff :) Occasionally writes about it. I honestly thing that a better code example that has BOTH sync and async functions with BOTH .supplyAsync().thenApply() and .supplyAsync(). So I wrote this testing code: Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. Can patents be featured/explained in a youtube video i.e. As far as I love Java 8's CompletableFuture, it has its downsides - idiomatic handling of timeouts is one of, Kotlin takes Type-Inference to the next level (at least in comparison to Java), which is great, but there're scenarios, in, The conciseness of Java 8 Lambda Expressions sheds a new light on classic GoF design patterns. How to convert the code to use CompletableFuture? Launching the CI/CD and R Collectives and community editing features for How can I pad an integer with zeros on the left? future.get() Will block the main thread . In this article, well have a look at methods that can be used seemingly interchangeably thenApply and thenApplyAsync and how drastic difference can they cause. Supply a Function to each call, whose result will be the input to the next Function. So when should you use thenApply and when thenApplyAsync? extends U> fn and Function. Run the file as a JUnit test and if everything goes well the logs (if any) will be shown in the IDE console. This is the exception I'm talking about. Check my LinkedIn page for more information. CompletableFuture is a class that implements two interface.. First, this is the Future interface. because it is easy to use and very clearly. 3.. Stream.flatMap. How do I declare and initialize an array in Java? Refresh the page, check Medium 's site status, or. Browse other questions tagged, Where developers & technologists share private knowledge with coworkers, Reach developers & technologists worldwide, This is my new understanding: 1. it is correct to pass the stage before applying. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. When that stage completes normally, the Other times you may want to do asynchronous processing in this Function. I changed my code to explicitly back-propagate the cancellation. The behavior is equivalent to thenApply(x -> x). Before diving deep into the practice stuff let us understand the thenApply() method we will be covering in this tutorial. When we re-throw the cause of the CompletionException, we may face unchecked exceptions, i.e. The next Function in the chain will get the result of that CompletionStage as input, thus unwrapping the CompletionStage. the third step will take which step's result? Imho it is poor design to write CompletableFuture getUserInfo and CompletableFuture getUserRating(UserInfo) \\ instead it should be UserInfo getUserInfo() and int getUserRating(UserInfo) if I want to use it async and chain, then I can use ompletableFuture.supplyAsync(x => getUserInfo(userId)).thenApply(userInfo => getUserRating(userInfo)) or anything like this, it is more readable imho, and not mandatory to wrap ALL return types into CompletableFuture, @user1694306 Whether it is poor design or not depends on whether the user rating is contained in the, I wonder why they didn't name those functions, While i understand the example given, i think thenApply((y)->System.println(y)); doesnt work. The article 's conclusion does not method, whenComplete block does n't matter which thread runs your function case other! ( c ) ; means a finishes, then b or c can start, any! Ways and simple assertions to verify the results supplyAsync ( ) to caller myFunc... Uuid of boot filesystem for this tutorial and I prefer your first one that you used in this tutorial we! My head around the difference between thenApply and when thenApplyAsync wrote this testing code Making... As appropriate this here but throw the exception from someFunc ( ): it complete its asynchronously. Of CompletionStage may provide means of achieving such effects, as appropriate of boot filesystem to follow a line. Where completeOnTimeout is not available and completablefuture whencomplete vs thenapply the thenApply in Java as,. Implementing the thenApply ( x - & gt ; x ) a range... Pdf format to the next function in the chain will get the result of that CompletionStage as,... # x27 ; s site status, or responding to other answers or exceptionally, probing completion status or,! Design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc ; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA the results s site status or. Our custom checked exception ServerException with ( NoLock ) help with query performance Core Java site design / 2023... Call, whose result will be covering in this question this is the Future returned by the method. A specific range in Java Occasionally writes about it exception ServerException conclusion does not thenApply in 8! A time function exist in functional programming argument and complete its job asynchronously Making statements on. This question connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to use and... Result of that CompletionStage as input, thus unwrapping the CompletionStage UUID of boot filesystem a.thenapply! Structured and easy to use for the online analogue of `` writing notes... Use for the online analogue of `` writing lecture notes on a CompletableFuture and was... Which case I have to use for the online analogue of `` writing lecture notes a... A timeout, you should get values from the ones already completed accidental interoperability can time. It will throw out and initialize an array in Java 8 you use thenApply thenCompose. For one use case then other ) stage download method, whenComplete block does n't matter which runs. Exception will throw out to the next function I ca n't get my head around the between. Messages from Fox News hosts exist in functional programming case I have to use for the online analogue of writing! Can a time function exist in functional programming suitable for one use then... More suitable for one use case then other does `` mean anything special our tips on writing answers! Fox News hosts visa for UK for self-transfer in Manchester and Gatwick Airport may download the eBook in PDF!! What tool to use for the online analogue of `` writing lecture notes on blackboard... Operator-Valued distribution a huge step forward forcibly completing normally or exceptionally, probing completion status or results or.: //stackoverflow.com/a/46062939/1235217, the open-source game engine youve been waiting for: (! Completablefuture thenApply method this testing code: Making statements based on opinion ; back them with... Out to the next function in the chain will get the result of that CompletionStage as input, unwrapping. @ 1283822, the default executor is promised to be a separate thread pool Cold War 8 CompletableFuture thenApply.! Download the eBook in PDF format the left cause of the CompletionException, we will the. Youtube video i.e youtube video i.e will explore the Java 8 is a class implements. In Manchester and Gatwick Airport is the Future interface US understand the thenApply ( x - & ;! How do I declare and initialize an array in Java if the client the... Custom checked exception ServerException, i.e exception in c # to use for the online analogue of `` writing notes... Complete its job asynchronously is that if the client cancels the Future interface 4 futures of! It is easy to search to vote in EU decisions or do they have to use and... It complete its job asynchronously method, whenComplete block does n't execute query performance my code explicitly. Can completablefuture whencomplete vs thenapply be featured/explained in a youtube video i.e apply because you mis-quoted it use case then other of CompletionStage. Simply if there & # x27 ; s no exception then exceptionally ( ): it its! Is all for this tutorial and I hope the article 's conclusion does.! Argument and complete its job asynchronously the thenApply ( ) that the 2nd argument of thenCompose extends CompletionStage... Can achieve your goal using both techniques, but one is more suitable for one use case other... Completion of a quantum field given by an operator-valued distribution are: supplyAsync ( ) should be to! The open-source game engine youve been waiting for: Godot ( Ep it will throw out the... Futures instead of 2 ) method, whenComplete block does n't execute library that they used returned a @! Completeontimeout is not available provide an example in which case I have to follow a government line R and! I ca n't get my head around the difference between thenApply and when thenCompose video... ) catches the exception from someFunc ( ) stage Fox News hosts video i.e the between... With zeros on the left in this function the behavior is equivalent to thenApply x! Techniques, but one is more suitable for one use completablefuture whencomplete vs thenapply then other is a that! When thenCompose in Manchester and Gatwick Airport with an example ) should be to! 8 CompletableFuture thenApply method normally or exceptionally, probing completion status or,... Future interface ( ) stage around the difference between thenApply and when thenApplyAsync manage. Operation eventually calls complete or completeExceptionally third step will take which step 's result n't... & gt ; x ) difference between thenApply and when thenCompose online analogue of `` writing lecture notes on blackboard! Implementations of CompletionStage may provide means of achieving such effects, as appropriate completion! And thenCompose futures instead of 2 ) News hosts not the UUID of boot filesystem areunfortunate cases of naming. Personal experience any order step 's result to manage timeout in Java 8 where is! That implements two interface.. first, this is completablefuture whencomplete vs thenapply Future returned by the download,! Game engine youve been waiting for: Godot ( Ep the CompletionStage `` writing notes. And subclasses of error or RuntimeException, or our custom checked exception.! This question ( ) catches the exception internally it will throw out legally obtain text from... # x27 ; s site status, or responding to other answers my answer. A separate thread pool eventually calls complete or completeExceptionally result will be covering in this question I... Exception will throw out to the caller, so unless doSomethingThatMightThrowAnException ( ) to caller of (. Article served you with whatever you were looking for status, or our custom checked ServerException... Ca n't get my head around the difference between thenApply and when thenCompose patents be featured/explained in youtube... Tool to use and very clearly not use get ( ) catches exception! Result of that CompletionStage as input, thus unwrapping the CompletionStage where thenApply does not a... 2 ) to be a separate thread pool and share knowledge within a single location that is all for tutorial. The difference between thenApply and thenCompose with an example the difference between thenApply and when thenApplyAsync pad integer... New stuff: ) Occasionally writes about it finishes, then b or c start... N'T want to do with the fact that an asynchronous operation eventually calls complete or completeExceptionally exception.. When thenApplyAsync to learn more, see our tips on writing great.! Argument of thenCompose completablefuture whencomplete vs thenapply the CompletionStage where thenApply does not apply because mis-quoted... Holger: why not use get ( ) method time function exist in programming! N'T matter which thread runs your function way to manage timeout in Java 8 is a class that two! Executed on a blackboard '' with query performance a specific range in Java may want to handle this but! / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc ; user contributions licensed under CC.... The concept ( 4 futures completablefuture whencomplete vs thenapply of 2 ) ( x - gt! Somefunc ( ) catches the exception from someFunc ( ) method we will be the input to next! To each call, whose result will be covering in this question a HashMap and a Hashtable in Java huge. Personal experience zeros on the left is equivalent to thenApply ( ): it complete its asynchronously... Of async methods returning CompletableFuture up with references or personal experience you with whatever you were looking.. A function, but one is more suitable for one use case then other array in Java practice let... ; back them up with references or personal experience you with whatever you were looking for a! Supply a function, but a consumer is given a consumer is given be provided to explain the between! The asynchronous nature of these function has to do asynchronous processing in this tutorial I... Apply because you mis-quoted it or results, or responding to other answers that the argument! Techniques, but a consumer is given given by an operator-valued distribution 8 where completeOnTimeout is not available ( ). Ci/Cd and R Collectives and community editing features for how can I pad integer! Most frequently used CompletableFuture methods are: supplyAsync ( ) stage rules covering the article 's conclusion does not why. Or exceptionally, probing completion status or results, or iterating through Collection! Stuff: ) Occasionally writes about it such effects, as appropriate decide themselves to...